Gather With Kate

The holidays are a time for sharing joy, and what better way than with a beautifully curated holiday cookie box? This year, my box features a mix of classic favorites, zesty treats, and rich indulgences that are perfect for gifting, sharing, or savoring on cozy nights in.

Here’s everything I’m including in my holiday cookie box this year, plus tips to make the process stress-free!

Tips for making Cookie Boxes

Creating a holiday cookie box doesn’t have to feel overwhelming! With a little planning, you can enjoy the process and still have time to savor the season.

1. Start early: Plan your recipes in early December so you know exactly what you want to bake.
2. Make a grocery list: Write out everything you’ll need and do your shopping ahead of time. This way, you can bake a batch whenever you have some free time.
3. Freeze what you can: Many cookie recipes freeze well, so make them in advance! For this cookie box:
   • Best for Freezing: The cranberry orange shortbread, gingerbread cookies, chocolate chip cookies, and lemon squares can all be made ahead and frozen.
   • Freezing Tips: The lemon raspberry thumbprint cookies also freeze well after baking but are best used within seven days.
4. Prepare cookie doughs in advance: Cookie doughs can be prepped and frozen, then brought to room temperature for about an hour before rolling out and baking.
5. Start with the easiest recipe: The lemon squares are quick to make and freeze beautifully for up to a month in an airtight container.

With these tips, you can spread out your baking, enjoy the process, and have everything ready when it’s time to assemble your cookie boxes!

What’s in This Year’s Cookie Box?

1. Lemon Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies

Bright, buttery cookies filled with tangy raspberry jam and kissed with lemon zest.

[Get the Recipe Here]

2. Cranberry Orange Shortbread

Rich, crumbly shortbread with dried cranberries and fresh orange zest.

[Get the Recipe Here]

3. Gingerbread Cookies with Royal Icing

Classic, spiced gingerbread cookies perfect for decorating with royal icing.

[Get the Recipe Here]

4. Chocolate Chip Cookies

Soft, chewy cookies packed with gooey chocolate chips.

[Get the Recipe Here]

5. Peanut Butter Cups

Homemade peanut butter cups for a rich, no-bake treat.

[Get the Recipe Here]

6. Lemon Squares

Tangy, buttery lemon squares that are as vibrant as they are delicious.

[Get the Recipe Here]

Assembling Your Cookie Box

Once your cookies are baked and ready, here’s how to put together a gorgeous cookie box:

• Choose a sturdy box: Line it with parchment paper or tissue paper.
• Separate flavors: Use cupcake liners or small dividers to keep cookies fresh and distinct.
• Add a personal touch: Write a holiday note or tie the box with festive ribbon.